Was anyone from the U. of Maine on the small college All-American teams from 1959-1961?
Answer: Manchester...
Thank you for your question; sorry to say that for the years you mentioned, no Maine Black Bear player made an All-American team.
I checked the NCAA Football Records Book and American Football Coaches Media Guide. The former publication has one player, Jim Huard, a LB being selected in 1965 and 66. He was a 1st team selection.